Chasing the Leprechaun: Why Your ‘Strategy’ Isn’t Working

In business, strategy is the leprechaun everyone’s hunting—mysterious, elusive, and rumored to hold the key to untold riches. But much like the fabled pot of gold, what many call “strategy” is just a shiny illusion. The real essence of strategy isn’t found in buzzwords or lofty visions—it’s in the grounded, unglamorous work of making tough choices and following through on them. Real strategy is about knowing exactly who you are as a company, understanding your customers and your place in the market, and relentlessly aligning your resources and culture to deliver on a clear value proposition. It’s not just about setting ambitious goals; it’s about defining what you won’t do, focusing your energy on what truly matters, and making sure every part of your organization is aligned to bring that vision to life.

What Does "Strategy" Really Mean?

At its core, strategy is about making deliberate, often difficult choices to achieve long-term objectives. As Michael Porter, a leading authority on strategy, emphasized, real strategy involves choosing a unique position in the market and aligning your resources and actions to maintain that position.

Good strategy requires:

• Understanding the Competitive Landscape: Who are your competitors, and how do you differentiate yourself?
• A Clear Value Proposition: Who are your customers, and why should they choose you over others?
• Sustainable Competitive Advantage: What can you do better, faster, or more effectively than competitors in a way that’s hard to replicate?
• Resource Allocation: Where should you focus your time, money, and energy for the most significant impact?

Why Does Strategy Often Feel Like Fluff?

1. Buzzwords Without Substance: Many companies use the word "strategy" as a catch-all term for broad goals. Phrases like “be the market leader” or “drive innovation” sound impressive but lack the specificity and actionable steps required to be truly strategic. Without a clear pathway, these are just slogans.
2. Execution Gaps: Even companies with well-thought-out strategies frequently fail when it comes to execution. This is where skepticism about "strategy experts" arises—plenty of people talk about strategy, but few guide their organizations toward meaningful action.
3. Strategy Must Be Owned, Not Outsourced: While consultants and Chief Strategy Officers (CSOs) can provide valuable frameworks and insights, real strategy can’t be fully outsourced. For a strategy to work, it must be deeply owned by the entire organization, from leadership to front-line employees. Ownership comes from clearly defining your company’s position, aligning it with who you are as a business, and creating a compelling message that resonates at every level.
4. Strategy vs. Operational Effectiveness: Many businesses confuse operational effectiveness (doing things well) with strategy (choosing what to do). Strategy is about making trade-offs, choosing a unique position, and deciding what not to do. However, even the best strategy will fail if it’s not executed effectively.

The Core Insight: Strategy Without Execution is Just Talk

At the heart of this discussion lies a simple truth: Strategy isn’t just about setting lofty goals; it’s about operationalizing those goals in a way that aligns the entire organization. Without disciplined execution, strategy becomes little more than wishful thinking.

In a previous article, I discussed how companies can fall into the trap of prioritizing growth without first establishing operational discipline. The same principle applies here: Effective strategy isn’t just about the big picture—it’s about the operational backbone that turns vision into reality. Success hinges on how well your organization integrates strategic intent into day-to-day processes, from decision-making frameworks to team incentives.

Conclusion: Strategy is Real—When Done Right

Strategy is often seen as a chase for elusive, glittering ideas, but the truth is more grounded. Real strategy isn’t a magical treasure hunt—it’s more like a carpenter’s hammer and nail. It’s about crafting a clear plan, driving each nail in with precision, and building something durable that stands the test of time. While everyone else is off chasing leprechauns, the companies that succeed are the ones that roll up their sleeves and do the deliberate, disciplined work of aligning their resources and actions every day.

‍